Skip to main content

Not every ask should be a robot, or a person

Automated or Manual Testimonial Requests

A personal note from the founder and an automated request triggered by an order are both good asks, for different customers. The mistake is choosing one style for everybody. Answer the questions below and the helper splits your requests: which ones to hand to an automation, which ones a person should write, and where the two meet.

  • Five questions about customers and volume
  • Automated, personal or a mix of both
  • Where a person hands off to the automation

Request style decider

Should this group get an automated or a personal ask?

Run it once per customer group, for example new buyers, retainer clients and partners. The answer is a starting point for that group, not a rule for your whole business.

How many people in this group finish working with you each month?
How well does someone on your team know each customer?
Is there a clear event that marks the right moment to ask?
What would an awkward ask cost you with this group?
Who has time to send and chase requests today?

Answers stay in this browser tab. Nothing is saved or sent.

The problem, solved

The trade-offs, and what StoryProof gives each side

Automations are available from Pro. Personal asks work on every plan.

  • Problem 1

    Personal asks keep getting forgotten

    The person who meant to write to each new customer had a busy month, and twenty good moments passed.

  • Problem 2

    Our best clients deserve a real note

    A big account that gets the same template as a one-off buyer reads it as a sign of how much you value them.

  • Problem 3

    We want personal asks but automatic reminders

    The founder will write the first note, but nobody will chase three days later.

  • Problem 4

    Automated asks hit people we already asked

    A personal request and an automated one land in the same week, and the customer wonders whether anyone talks to each other.

  • Problem 5

    The trigger lives in another tool

    Orders and paid invoices are recorded in your shop or billing system, so an automation cannot see the moment.

Automated and personal asks compared

Automated requestPersonal request
TimingSet by a trigger or a scheduleSet by someone’s judgement
ScaleAny volume your email allowance coversAs many as one person can write
ToneYour template with merge tagsWritten for one customer
RemindersBuilt into the flowOnly if someone remembers
Best forMany customers, clear eventsFew customers, high stakes

In StoryProof

Put the split into practice

  1. 1

    Keep every group in your contacts

    Contacts and Smart Lists are on every plan, so automated and personal groups can sit side by side in one place.

  2. 2

    Automate the high-volume groups

    Start a request from the event that marks the moment, with reminders and quiet hours set before you publish.

  3. 3

    Write the personal asks yourself

    For high-stakes groups, a named person sends a short note with the collection link. Requests from StoryProof go by email; the personal note can go however you normally speak to that client.

  4. 4

    Hand off the reminders

    For hybrid groups, add the customer to the reminder automation by hand once the personal note has gone.

What happens next: Revisit the split when a group grows. A group that was five customers a month last year may be thirty now.

Before you start

What to weigh before you switch

What this does not cover, and what to check on your side. Better to know now than after launch.

  1. 01

    Automation is on paid plans

    Automations start at Pro. On a lower plan, the hybrid becomes a personal ask plus a calendar reminder.

  2. 02

    Requests use a monthly allowance

    Review request emails are counted per month, so a high-volume automation needs a plan whose allowance covers it.

  3. 03

    Email only from StoryProof

    StoryProof sends requests by email, not SMS. A personal ask in another channel has to come from you.

  4. 04

    The helper is a rule of thumb

    Scores come from your answers, not from response data. Watch who actually replies and adjust.

FAQ

Questions people ask

Short answers to what usually comes up next.

Do automated requests get fewer replies than personal ones?

We do not publish response figures. Compare your own: run both styles for a few weeks and count testimonials received from each group.

Can I personalise an automated request?

Emails sent by an automation support merge tags, such as the customer’s name. That makes it addressed to them, though it is still the same template.

What if someone gets both a personal and an automated ask?

Use the review request action that skips people asked recently, and add hybrid customers to the automation only after the personal note is sent.

Is a hybrid more work than either style alone?

Slightly more to set up, less to run. The person writes one note per customer and never has to remember to chase.

Still have a question? Ask the StoryProof team or book a demo.

Automate the asks that do not need you

Keep the personal notes for the clients who deserve them, and let reminders run on their own.

Sources

  1. Automations, StoryProof. Checked 2026-11-18.

Last updated 2026-11-18.