Skip to main content

Postmark as your sending account

Testimonial Requests Through Postmark SMTP

You already trust Postmark with receipts and password resets, and you would like testimonial requests to leave from the same domain with the same reputation work behind them. Postmark accepts mail over SMTP, so it can act as the SMTP account behind your StoryProof requests. The checklist below walks through the Postmark side in the order Postmark expects it, with the questions to settle before the first real customer gets an email.

  • Domain verification, stream and token in order
  • An SMTP token so no custom header is needed
  • A test plan that ends in your own inbox first

Postmark checklist

Get Postmark ready to carry your requests

Tick each item as you finish it in Postmark. Items with a source come from Postmark’s own help pages as read on 2026-11-17.

1. Account and domain
2. Stream and credentials
3. StoryProof and the first send

Your ticks stay in this browser tab and are not sent anywhere.

The problem, solved

What changes when Postmark sends for you

Postmark handles delivery. StoryProof still decides who gets asked, when, and what they can send back.

  • Problem 1

    Requests should come from our real domain

    Customers know your company address from receipts. A request from somewhere else looks like a different sender and earns less trust.

  • Problem 2

    We only want to ask the right customers

    Postmark reviews accounts to protect its sending reputation, and a stale list full of old addresses works against yours.

  • Problem 3

    Reminders must not pile up

    Several unanswered emails in a row are what turns a polite ask into a complaint, and complaints count against your Postmark reputation.

  • Problem 4

    Postmark is still pending approval

    A new Postmark account cannot reach outside addresses yet, but the customer you just finished a project with is ready now.

  • Problem 5

    Can Postmark send text messages too?

    Some teams expect a delivery provider to open more channels. Postmark is an email service, and StoryProof requests are email.

In StoryProof

From a Postmark server to a first customer request

Step 1 of 4

Verify the domain in Postmark

Add the domain under Sender Signatures, publish the DKIM TXT record and the pm_bounces Return-Path CNAME, then wait for both to show as verified.

Postmark settings at a glance

Read from Postmark’s SMTP and domain verification help pages on 2026-11-17. Postmark may change them.
SettingValue from Postmark docsNote
Hostsmtp.postmarkapp.comsmtp-broadcasts.postmarkapp.com for a broadcast stream
Port587, 2525 or 25587 with STARTTLS is the usual choice
UsernameSMTP token Access KeyOr a server API token if a stream header can be set
PasswordSMTP token Secret KeyShown once, store it safely
From addressAny address on a verified domainOr one confirmed sender signature

Before you start

What this guide does not cover

  • Steps follow Postmark’s docs as of 2026-11-17

    Every Postmark step here comes from Postmark’s help pages on that date and has not been followed on a live account by our team. Check the current docs if a screen looks different.

  • Which stream is yours to decide

    Postmark’s pages do not say where review requests belong. If you are unsure whether your sends are transactional or broadcast, ask Postmark before your first batch.

  • StoryProof field names are not described

    This page does not describe the exact screens in StoryProof. Look for where the app asks for your own SMTP account.

  • Delivery is never certain

    Verified records and a good provider lower the odds of a request being filtered. Each mailbox still makes its own decision.

FAQ

Questions people ask

Short answers to what usually comes up next.

Do I need a sender signature or a verified domain?

One or the other. Postmark asks for a sender signature for each From address, or a verified domain, which then lets any address on that domain send.

Why use an SMTP token rather than the server API token?

With the server API token, Postmark picks the stream from a header in the message. An SMTP token belongs to one stream already, so nothing extra has to be added to each email.

My test request never arrived. What should I check first?

Look in Postmark Activity. If nothing is there, the credentials or host are wrong. If it shows as sent, check that the account is approved and that the recipient is allowed while approval is pending.

Is Postmark one of the providers StoryProof names?

StoryProof names SendGrid, Mailgun, Mailchimp or any SMTP account. Postmark connects as an SMTP account.

Still have a question? Ask the StoryProof team or book a demo.

Send requests from your own domain

Connect your SMTP account, pick recent customers and let StoryProof handle the asking and the follow ups.

Sources

  1. Send email with SMTP, Postmark. Checked 2026-11-17.
  2. How do I verify a domain?, Postmark. Checked 2026-11-17.
  3. How to create and send through message streams, Postmark. Checked 2026-11-17.
  4. How does the account approval process work?, Postmark. Checked 2026-11-17.
  5. Getting started with Postmark, Postmark. Checked 2026-11-17.

Last updated 2026-11-17.