Skip to main content

One submission does not add up

Verify a Testimonial Is Genuine First

A glowing testimonial lands from a name nobody on the team recognises. It praises a feature you shipped last week and arrived an hour after the order was placed, before the parcel left the warehouse. Maybe it is a keen customer. Maybe it is not. Work through the checks below on that one submission before it goes anywhere near your website.

  • Checks for one doubtful submission, not a bulk filter
  • Uses your own order and contact records
  • Ends with approve, hold or decline

The problem, solved

Where a doubtful submission causes trouble

StoryProof cannot tell you who someone really is. What it can do is keep the doubtful one out of sight while a person checks it properly.

Situation 1 of 5

It looked fine, so someone approved it

A busy teammate clears the queue on a Friday and the strange one goes live with the rest.

How StoryProof solves it

Nothing a customer submits goes public until it is approved, so a submission under review stays private for as long as the check takes.

Authenticity checks

Check this one submission before approving it

Open the submission beside your order system and inbox. Tick each check you have done. You do not need every box: two or three solid matches usually settle it.

Match it to your records
Read what they wrote
Look at the attachments
Confirm with the sender

Ticks stay in this page only. Nothing you tick is stored or sent.

What the checks usually point to

Illustrative combinations, not rules. Your own records decide.

What you foundLikely readingWhat to do
Order matches, details right, reply receivedA real customerApprove and thank them
Order matches, no reply after a weekProbably real, unconfirmedKeep it private, try once more, then decide
No order, details right, sender replies with an order numberBought through a reseller or under another nameCheck that order, then approve
No order, feature you do not sell, no replyNot a customerKeep it unapproved, tag it, move on
Wording found on another company’s siteCopied textDo not publish

In StoryProof

Run the check in StoryProof

  1. 1

    Hold and tag it

    Leave it unapproved and add a tag such as "checking origin" so the whole team knows it is open.

  2. 2

    Match it against records

    Search your order system for the name and email, and compare the product and dates with what the testimonial says.

  3. 3

    Write to the customer

    Use the email address from your own records. Thank them, ask them to confirm they sent it, and offer the collection link if they would like to resubmit.

  4. 4

    Decide and clear the tag

    Approve it, or keep it private with a note on why. Filter by the tag weekly so nothing stays open for long.

What happens next: If the same pattern turns up again, such as a burst from free addresses with no orders, write it down. It is a candidate for an automatic rule, not a weekly chore.

Before you start

What this check cannot do

  • StoryProof does not verify identity

    There is no identity check, purchase check or fake detection in the product. The checks on this page are done by you, against your own records.

  • A match is evidence, not proof

    Someone can use a real customer’s name. A reply from the email address on the order is the stronger signal.

  • Not every real customer is in your system

    Gifts, resellers and company cards mean a genuine reviewer may not match any order. Ask before you decide.

  • The law here needs a reviewer

    The FTC rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, in force since 21 October 2024, can make a business liable for fake testimonials it writes or buys, and its guidance points to warning signs a business should not ignore. Have a qualified person confirm how it applies to you.

  • Do not collect more than you need

    Asking for a passport or a screenshot of a bank statement is out of proportion for a testimonial. An order number is enough.

FAQ

Questions people ask

Short answers to what usually comes up next.

Can StoryProof tell me whether a testimonial is fake?

No. It keeps every submission private until you approve it and lets you tag the ones you are checking, but the judgement uses your own records and a reply from the customer.

Is it rude to ask a customer to confirm they wrote it?

Not if you lead with thanks. "Thank you for this, can you confirm it came from you before we share it?" reads as care, not suspicion.

What if the reviewer is real but bought through a partner?

Ask for the order reference or where they bought. A partner sale will not be in your records, and a quick reply usually clears it up.

Should I delete a submission that fails the checks?

Keep it unapproved with a tag and a short note on why. That record helps if similar submissions arrive later.

Does this apply to reviews I import from other sites?

The same records check applies, and imports wait for approval too. The difference is that the review platform has its own rules on who may post.

Still have a question? Ask the StoryProof team or book a demo.

Check first, publish second

Every submission waits for your approval, so a doubtful one never reaches your site while you look into it.

Sources

  1. Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers, Federal Trade Commission. Checked 2026-11-20.

Last updated 2026-11-20.