Pinning and featuring
Pin Your Best Testimonials First
Your strongest review is often buried under last week's polite one-liners. From Pro, an automation can feature a testimonial and pin it to the top the moment it meets the bar you set, so the order reflects quality instead of arrival time.
- Write down what earns a pin before automating it
- Feature, pin and label in one flow
- Keep the pinned set short and reviewed
The problem, solved
Why the best review ends up at the bottom
Most widgets fill in arrival order. These are the situations that push strong proof out of sight, and the StoryProof step for each.
Situation 1 of 5
Every new review shoves the good ones down
A widget that leads with the newest entry rewards volume, so a detailed story from March sits below three short thank-yous from this week.
How StoryProof solves it
From Pro, an automation can pin favourites to the top, so the testimonials you rate highest hold their place as new ones arrive.
Situation 2 of 5
Nobody has time to re-sort after approvals
Manual ordering works for a week. Then a busy month passes and the order is whatever happened to land.
How StoryProof solves it
Start the automation when a testimonial is approved, so the pin is applied at the same moment the review clears moderation.
Situation 3 of 5
Which testimonials actually deserve a pin?
Without a rule, the pinned set reflects whoever was in the dashboard that day and what caught their eye.
How StoryProof solves it
Use the rating rule an automation already applies to approvals, such as 4 and 5 stars with text, as the starting point for what gets featured.
Situation 4 of 5
I cannot tell which reviews were pinned automatically
When a person and a rule both pin things, nobody remembers why a review sits at the top.
How StoryProof solves it
Add a label in the same flow as the pin, and read the automation logs to see each run and why it ended.
Situation 5 of 5
Could the rule pin something we never approved?
Teams worry that automating the top slot means unvetted text ends up front and centre.
How StoryProof solves it
Nothing goes public until it is approved, and you still choose which approved testimonials each widget shows.
Pinning rule
Decide what earns the top spot
Tick through this before you publish the automation. A pin rule written down is one the whole team can argue about once, instead of every week.
Ticks stay in your browser. Nothing is saved or sent.
In StoryProof
Set up automatic pinning
- 1
Start a new automation from an approval
In the automation builder, pick the trigger for a testimonial being approved. Work saves as you go and nothing runs before you publish.
- 2
Add your rule as a condition
Name the matching branch after your rule so the canvas explains itself to the next person who opens it.
- 3
Feature, pin and label on the matching branch
Add the actions to feature the testimonial, pin it to the top and add a label you can filter by later.
- 4
Publish, then read the logs
After the next few approvals, open the logs and confirm each run did what the rule says. Logs are kept for 30 days.
What happens next: Put the monthly unpin review in the calendar of whoever owns the widgets.
Before you start
What pinning by rule will not do
It does not judge quality for you
The rule only sees what you tell it to check. A five-star review with a vague sentence can still match, so read the pinned set yourself.
No display order promises here
This page does not describe how pinned testimonials are arranged inside each widget layout or when visitors see the change. Check your widget after the first pin.
Pins pile up unless you prune them
The automation adds pins; it is the monthly review that keeps the top of the list fresh.
Plan gated
Pinning by automation needs Pro or above. Below that, choose and arrange widget testimonials by hand.
A test run is real
Running a test performs every step, so a test pins a real testimonial. Unpin it afterwards or test on one you would pin anyway.
FAQ
Questions people ask
Short answers to what usually comes up next.
Can I still pin a testimonial by hand?
This page covers pinning through an automation. Whatever you pin by hand, give it the same label as the rule uses so the monthly review catches both.
What is the difference between featuring and pinning?
They are separate automation actions. Many teams use both together on the matching branch; decide what featured means for your widgets and write it into the rule.
Will pinning a testimonial publish it?
No. The flow starts after approval, and nothing reaches your site until someone has approved it.
How many testimonials should be pinned?
There is no right number, but a short pinned set reads as a curated choice. If the label filter shows a long list, it is time to unpin some.
Still have a question? Ask the StoryProof team or book a demo.
Put your strongest proof first
Collect and approve testimonials in StoryProof, then let an automation pin the ones that meet your bar.
Last updated 2026-11-18.