Skip to main content
Agency PlaybookAgency TestimonialsClient TestimonialsAgenciesCollect Testimonials

Client Testimonials for Agencies: One System for Every Brand

Agencies need testimonials twice over: about the agency, and for each client brand. A repeatable system with one workspace per client, a monthly routine and approvals on both sides.

StoryProof Team8 min read

Agencies need testimonials twice over. You need proof for your own website, from the clients you serve. And most of your clients need proof for theirs, from their own customers, which they often expect you to collect, approve and publish for them. Done one client at a time, with a different spreadsheet and a different email for each, it never runs smoothly.

This guide sets out one system for agency client testimonials that works across every brand: a separate workspace per client, clear rules on who asks, a monthly routine, approvals on both sides, and a simple way to show results. If you are still choosing a tool, start with our comparison of testimonial software for agencies.

Two kinds of agency testimonials

Treat these as separate streams with separate owners, even though the same team runs both.

The two testimonial streams an agency manages
Testimonials about your agencyTestimonials for a client brand
Who gives themYour clientsYour client’s customers
Where they appearYour website, proposals, pitch decks, case studiesThe client’s website, ads, emails and social
Who approvesThe client who gave itThe customer who gave it, then the client
Whose brand is on the formYoursThe client’s

Scroll the table sideways to compare

Mixing them causes real problems: a client’s customer receiving a request with your agency’s logo, or your own testimonials sitting in a client’s library where their team can see them.

Set up one workspace per client

Give every client a separate workspace, and keep one for your own agency. Each workspace holds that brand’s logo and colours, its collection forms, its contacts, its widgets, its Wall of Love and its team. A teammate added to one client’s workspace never sees another client’s reviews.

In StoryProof a workspace is called a space. Pro includes 3 spaces with 5 seats each, and Agency includes 15 spaces with 10 seats each, so an agency can run its own space plus a space per client. You switch between them from the dashboard header.

Access is set per area of the workspace, so you can match it to how you work:

  • Account managers: write access to testimonials, forms, widgets and contacts for their own clients only.
  • Client contacts: read access to testimonials, so they can see what has come in, without changing widgets or billing.
  • Agency leads: access across all spaces, including billing.

One thing to know before you promise it to a client: StoryProof is not a white-label product. Forms, widgets and emails carry the client’s branding, and on Pro and above you can remove the “Powered by StoryProof” badge from widgets, but the app itself stays StoryProof.

Decide who asks: the agency or the client

Customers answer a request from a brand they know far more readily than one from an agency they have never heard of. Agree up front which model each client uses:

Who should send testimonial requests for a client
ModelHow it worksBest when
Client sends, agency runsYou set up the form and the request in the client’s branding; it goes out in the client’s nameMost clients. Highest response, least effort for the client
Client sends, client runsYou set up the system and train the client’s team to use itClients with their own marketing team
Agency sendsRequests come from your agency on the client’s behalfRarely. Only when customers know your agency by name

Scroll the table sideways to compare

For the first model, send from the client’s own domain where you can. On Pro and above, StoryProof can send review requests through your own SendGrid, Mailgun, Mailchimp Transactional or SMTP account, set in each space’s settings, after a test message confirms it works.

The monthly testimonial routine

Run the same checklist for every client, once a month. Once the forms and campaigns exist, it becomes a short monthly task per client rather than a project.

  1. 1Week 1, pick who to ask. Pull the client’s customers who reached a result this month: delivered orders, finished projects, renewals.
  2. 2Week 1, send the requests. One campaign per client, in the client’s branding and name.
  3. 3Week 2, remind once. Only to people who have not answered. One reminder is usually enough for a client campaign.
  4. 4Week 3, approve. Moderate new submissions, tag them by product, service or objection, and send the shortlist to the client for sign-off.
  5. 5Week 4, publish and report. Add approved testimonials to the client’s widgets and Wall of Love, then send the client a short summary.

Our complete guide to collecting customer testimonials covers each step in more depth, from timing to consent.

Collecting testimonials about your agency

Your own testimonials come from clients, so ask at moments that prove your work: a launch, a results review, a renewal, the end of a project. Ask the person who saw the result, and make it easy with three questions: what was the situation before, what did we do, and what changed?

Our testimonial request email templates include ready-made emails for project handover, results reviews and long-standing clients. Results with numbers persuade most, so ask permission to name the company and quote the figure, and respect a client who prefers to stay anonymous.

Collecting testimonials for your clients’ customers

For each client brand, use the channels their customers already use:

  • Email campaigns to customer lists, timed after delivery or a result. For ecommerce clients, our post-purchase review request playbook covers the timing.
  • QR codes on packaging, receipts and in-store signage for local and retail clients. See our guide to QR codes for reviews.
  • Imports of reviews the client already has on Google, Trustpilot and other sites, so new and existing proof sit in one library.

Ask every customer who reached a result, not only the happiest ones. Selective asking is the pattern review platforms ban, and our guide to review gating explains why.

Approvals and the rules agencies must follow

Agencies are not exempt from the rules on fake reviews. The FTC’s guidance on its Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule, in effect since 21 October 2024, says that agencies, PR firms, review brokers and reputation management companies “are not immune from liability” and could be liable if they write, create or sell a fake or false consumer review (FTC, “Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers” (opens in a new tab)).

In practice that gives an agency four rules:

  1. 1Never write a testimonial for a client’s customer, or polish one until it says something the customer did not.
  2. 2Get the customer’s permission for how their words, name and photo are used. A permission step in the form records it.
  3. 3Get the client’s sign-off before anything goes on their site. Moderation means nothing appears until it is approved.
  4. 4Do not hide critical reviews because of their rating. Remove spam, abuse or private details using the same rules for everyone.

This is general information, not legal advice. If a client works in a regulated industry, check their own rules too.

Show results on the client’s site and on yours

For each client, embed widgets on the pages where their customers decide, and give them a Wall of Love page to link to. Our page-by-page guide to where to put testimonials on your website shows which layout fits each spot.

For your own agency site, the strongest proof is a client describing a result you delivered. Put it on your service pages and pricing page, and use it in proposals and pitch decks matched to the prospect’s industry.

Report the results to each client

Collection becomes a service a client values when they can see it working. Each StoryProof space has its own analytics: how many reviews came in and from where, the average rating, approval rate, and how each widget is performing. A short monthly note per client is enough:

  • New testimonials collected, and how many were video.
  • Average rating this month.
  • Widget views and interactions on their site.
  • The best new testimonial, quoted, with where it now appears.

Frequently asked questions

How do agencies collect testimonials for clients?

Set up a separate workspace per client with that brand’s form and branding, send requests to the client’s customers in the client’s name, approve submissions with the client, and publish them in widgets on the client’s site. A monthly routine keeps it consistent across clients.

Can an agency write testimonials for a client?

No. The FTC’s Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule covers fake or false reviews, and the FTC says agencies are not immune from liability if they write, create or sell them. Collect real testimonials from real customers, with their permission.

Should testimonial requests come from the agency or the client?

Usually from the client, in their branding and ideally from their own email domain, because customers respond to a brand they know. The agency can still run the whole process behind the scenes.

How do agencies get testimonials for their own website?

Ask clients at moments that prove your work: a launch, a results review, a renewal or the end of a project. Ask three questions about before, what you did and what changed, and get permission to name the company and any figures.

See how it works for your agency

Running testimonials for several clients is easier to judge on a call than on a pricing page. Book a demo and we will walk through spaces, permissions and reporting with your client list in mind, or see how StoryProof works for agencies. You can also start a 7-day free trial (opens in a new tab), no credit card needed.

Sources

Let your customers make the case for you

Put your customers’ own words on the pages that sell. Start your 7-day free trial today.

Nothing to install • 7 days free • No credit card required