Skip to main content
Complete GuideReview AggregationImport ReviewsReview WidgetGoogle Reviews

How to Bring All Your Reviews Into One Place

Your reviews are spread across Google, Trustpilot, G2, Facebook and more, and buyers rarely see them all. How to bring them into one library, keep them in sync, and show them together.

StoryProof Team10 min read

Most businesses already have more reviews than they realise. The problem is where they live: a few on Google, some on Trustpilot or G2, a handful on Facebook, kind words in emails and Slack. Buyers rarely see more than one of those places, and almost none of it reaches your own website, where people actually decide.

This guide shows how to bring all your reviews into one place: how to find where they are, which platforms can sync automatically, how to bring in the rest by hand or by CSV, how to moderate them fairly, and how to show them together on your site. It is the hub for our guides on importing reviews from each platform, starting with Google and Trustpilot.

Why scattered reviews never reach buyers

Buyers do not rely on one review site. In BrightLocal’s Local Consumer Review Survey 2026, a panel of 1,002 US adults, consumers used an average of six review sites, and Google’s share fell from 83% in 2025 to 71% (BrightLocal, “Local Consumer Review Survey 2026” (opens in a new tab), published 11 February 2026).

That cuts both ways. A buyer who only checks Trustpilot never sees your strong Google rating. A buyer on your website sees none of it unless you put it there. Every review left on a platform your visitor does not check is proof you earned but cannot use.

Bringing reviews into one place fixes three problems at once:

  • Visibility. Reviews from every source can appear on your own pages, next to the decision.
  • Management. One library to read, moderate, tag and search, instead of logging in to six dashboards.
  • Freshness. New reviews arrive on their own, so the proof on your site never goes stale.

What review aggregation means

Review aggregation means you aggregate reviews from several platforms into one library and show them together. It is different from embedding one platform’s own widget. A Trustpilot widget shows Trustpilot reviews; a Google widget shows Google reviews. An aggregated widget shows both, plus any other source, in one design that matches your site.

One widget per platform vs aggregated reviews
One widget per platformAggregated reviews
Sources shownOne eachAll of them, labelled by source
DesignEach platform’s own styleOne style that matches your site
Scripts on the pageOne per platformOne
ModerationPer platform, often noneOne queue for everything
Your own testimonialsNot includedShown alongside imported reviews

Scroll the table sideways to compare

Step 1: Audit where your reviews live

Before you connect anything, make a list. For each platform, note how many reviews you have, the average rating, and the date of the most recent one. That tells you where to start and which platforms are going stale.

Most businesses find their reviews in a predictable set of places:

Where reviews usually live, by type of business
BusinessWhere to look
Local servicesGoogle, Facebook, Yelp
EcommerceYour store’s product reviews (Shopify), Amazon, Trustpilot, Trusted Shops
B2B softwareG2, Capterra, TrustRadius, Product Hunt
Hospitality and travelGoogle, Tripadvisor, Booking.com, Airbnb
AppsGoogle Play, Apple App Store
Consultants and freelancersLinkedIn recommendations, Google, client emails
EmployersGlassdoor

Scroll the table sideways to compare

Add the places nobody thinks of as review sites: thank-you emails, support chats, Slack messages, social comments. They often hold the most specific praise you have.

Step 2: Connect platforms that sync automatically

For the main review platforms, connecting once is enough. You paste the link to your business profile, the first import goes back through your history, and later syncs bring in only what is new.

StoryProof syncs automatically from Google, Trustpilot, G2, Capterra, TrustRadius, Product Hunt, Shopify, Amazon, Facebook, Yelp, Tripadvisor, Booking.com, Airbnb, Trusted Shops, Glassdoor and Google Play. Each connection shows when it last synced, how many reviews it added, and whether it is healthy.

Automatic sync starts on Starter. Starter connects 1 platform, Pro 5 and Agency 10. On Free, you can still paste reviews in by hand. Start with the platform where you have the most recent reviews, or the one your buyers check first.

Step 3: Paste in reviews from platforms that cannot sync

Some platforms do not allow automatic import. For those, copy each review in by hand with its author, rating, date and source, so it shows with the right attribution.

In StoryProof, reviews from LinkedIn, the Apple App Store, AppSumo, Bol.com, Goodreads, Apple Podcasts, Docfinder and Zillow are added this way, on every plan. Anything else, from any source, can be added manually too.

For LinkedIn recommendations in particular, ask the person before you publish them on your site. They wrote for your profile, not your homepage.

Step 4: Bulk-import reviews with a CSV

If you are moving from another review tool, or you have reviews in a spreadsheet, a CSV import is quicker than pasting one by one. Export from the old tool, map its columns to the review fields (author, rating, text, date, source), and upload.

Before you import, clean the file: remove duplicates, check the dates came across correctly, and make sure each row says where the review came from. Video testimonials you already have can be uploaded as files.

Step 5: Bring in praise from email, chat and Slack

Some of your best proof was never posted anywhere: a customer’s thank-you email, a message in a shared Slack channel, a comment on a support ticket. Ask the customer whether you may publish it, then add it manually with their name, the date and where it came from.

Our testimonial request email templates include one for asking permission to use praise you already have.

Step 6: Moderate before you display

Imported reviews land in the same library as everything else, and nothing appears on your site until it is approved. That gives you one place to read every review, tag it by product or topic, and decide what goes where.

Moderate with the same rules for every review. Remove spam, abuse, private information and reviews that are not about your business. Do not remove a review because it is critical. Under the FTC’s rule on consumer reviews, leaving reviews out because of their rating or negative sentiment, while implying the ones you show are representative, can be deceptive (16 CFR 465.7 (opens in a new tab)). Our guide to review gating explains the related platform rules. This is general information, not legal advice.

Moderation rules can speed this up, for example approving reviews automatically from a trusted source, while everything else waits for a person.

Step 7: Show reviews from every source together

Once reviews are in one library, one widget can show them all, each labelled with its source. Three ways to present them:

  • Mixed together: a Review Grid or Testimonial Wall with each card showing a small source label. Best when volume is the argument.
  • By platform: a header with a tab per platform, so visitors can switch between Google, Trustpilot and the rest.
  • As scores: a Rating Breakdown showing your average on each platform, or a compact Rating Badge with the overall score near a button.

Our page-by-page guide to where to put testimonials on your website shows which layout fits each spot, and our guide to choosing a review widget covers the basics.

Respect each platform’s display rules

Review platforms set their own rules for showing their reviews elsewhere. They commonly cover attribution (naming or showing the platform), linking back to the original review or profile, not editing review text, and how ratings and logos may be shown. The rules differ by platform and change over time, so check each one before you publish.

Our guides cover the rules for Google reviews and Trustpilot reviews. Guides for other platforms follow as they are published.

Keep reviews fresh

Recency matters to buyers. In the same BrightLocal survey, 74% of consumers looked for reviews written in the last three months, and 18% were only swayed by reviews from the last week.

Three habits keep aggregated reviews current:

  1. 1Let connections sync. Check the connection status now and then, and fix any that are flagged as broken.
  2. 2Watch the import history. Every import run is logged with its source, time and result, so a failed import does not go unnoticed. In-app notifications flag finished and failed imports and broken connections.
  3. 3Rotate what you show. Use a layout that puts the newest first, such as Timeline, and swap out old quotes on key pages.

On Pro and above, automations can act on import events, for example alerting the team when a connection breaks or when a new review is detected on a platform.

Combine imported reviews with testimonials you collect

Imported reviews tell buyers that many people are happy. Testimonials you collect yourself, especially on video, tell them why. The two work best together, in the same library and the same widgets.

Our complete guide to collecting customer testimonials covers the collecting side. Imported and collected reviews count towards the same monthly allowance of new reviews.

Common import problems and how to fix them

Most problems with aggregated reviews come from a handful of causes. Each has a simple fix.

  • The same review appears twice. This usually happens when a CSV includes reviews that a connected platform also syncs. Remove synced platforms from the CSV before you upload it, and delete any duplicates you find.
  • Dates are wrong or missing. Spreadsheets often change date formats. Check a few rows after import, fix the dates in the file, and import again.
  • A connection stops syncing. The profile link may have changed, or the platform may have blocked the request. The connection status shows when this happens. Reconnect with the current profile link.
  • A review disappears from the platform. The reviewer may have deleted it, or the platform may have removed it. In most cases, stop showing it on your site too.
  • Ratings use different scales. Some platforms use stars, others use scores out of ten or a simple recommend. Keep each review labelled with its source, so visitors read the rating in context.

On Pro and above, automations can also run when a review disappears at its source, so the team hears about it without checking by hand.

What to look for in a review aggregation tool

If you are choosing a tool to aggregate reviews, check these points against your own list from Step 1:

  1. 1Your platforms sync. The platforms where you have the most reviews should import automatically, not by hand.
  2. 2The rest can be added. Manual paste and CSV import cover the platforms that cannot sync, and reviews from email or chat.
  3. 3One moderation queue. Every review, from every source, waits for approval in one place.
  4. 4Clear source labels. Each review shows where it came from, with a link back where the platform requires one.
  5. 5Design you control. Layouts, colours and fonts match your site, with a separate mobile layout.
  6. 6Fast loading. The widget loads asynchronously, so it does not slow the page.
  7. 7Pricing that fits. Check how many platforms you can connect on each plan, and whether reviews you collect yourself count toward the same limit.

Our buyer’s guide to testimonial software compares the main tools in more depth.

Plan limits for importing reviews

Importing reviews on each StoryProof plan
PlanPlatforms syncing automaticallyNew reviews per monthManual and CSV import
Free025Yes
Starter1100Yes
Pro5UnlimitedYes
Agency10UnlimitedYes

Scroll the table sideways to compare

See the import page for every source and the pricing page for full plan details.

Frequently asked questions

What is review aggregation?

Review aggregation is collecting reviews from several platforms, such as Google, Trustpilot, G2 and Facebook, into one library, then showing them together on your website in one widget, each labelled with its source.

Can I combine Google and Trustpilot reviews in one widget?

Yes. A review aggregation tool imports from both and shows them in one widget, mixed together, in tabs per platform, or as a score breakdown per platform. Check each platform’s display rules for attribution and linking.

Do imported reviews update automatically?

For platforms that support automatic sync, yes: after the first import, new reviews are pulled in on their own. Platforms that do not allow it need reviews pasted in by hand.

Should I import negative reviews too?

Yes. Approve reviews with the same rules for everyone and remove only spam, abuse, private information or reviews unrelated to your business. Hiding reviews because they are critical can mislead buyers and can break the FTC’s rule on review suppression.

How many review platforms does StoryProof import from?

StoryProof imports from 24 review platforms. Some sync automatically on paid plans; the rest are added by pasting the review in, which works on every plan.

Bring your reviews together this week

Make your list of review platforms today, connect the one with the most recent reviews, and paste in your five best from everywhere else. Start a 7-day free trial of StoryProof (opens in a new tab) to import from 24 platforms into one library and show them in one widget, no credit card needed.

Sources

Let your customers make the case for you

Put your customers’ own words on the pages that sell. Start your 7-day free trial today.

Nothing to install • 7 days free • No credit card required